Feedback as a Leadership Superpower: Turning Conversations into Growth

While I'm on a brief break this August, I'm drawing inspiration from my book 52 Meditations on Working and Living Authentically. You can access it for free at https://www.mike-horne.com/free-books.

Feedback often gets a bad rap in workplaces. People cringe at the word, associating it with performance reviews, tension-filled meetings, or one-sided critiques that fail to inspire improvement. But what if we flipped the narrative? What if feedback wasn't something to fear, but a leadership superpower that could transform not just individuals, but entire organizations?

To lead authentically, feedback can't be treated as an occasional, top-down directive. It must become a tool for connection, learning, and growth. Drawing insights from my book, The People Dividend: Leadership Strategies for Unlocking Employee Potential, alongside meditations from 52 Meditations on Working and Living Authentically, we'll explore how to reframe feedback as a growth catalyst. We'll also look at practical, actionable ways to integrate feedback into everyday leadership—and why doing so might be the strategic edge your organization needs.

Redefining Feedback as a Two-Way Discovery

Most people think of feedback as a one-sided exchange. A manager tells their employee what they're doing wrong—and maybe sprinkles in a bit of what they're doing right. But feedback, when used effectively, is a dialogue—a robust, two-way discovery process.

One of my favorite meditations from 52 Meditations on Working and Living Authentically is "Approach Feedback as a Discovery Tool." It underscores a critical point: feedback has as much to teach the giver as the receiver. When we frame feedback as a conversation designed for mutual learning, it becomes a tool not for judgment, but for growth and connection.

Here's an example. When you ask an employee for their thoughts before giving feedback—"How do you think your presentation went?" or "What would you improve about that meeting?"—you open the door to self-reflection and make the process collaborative. This approach not only fosters trust but helps you understand their perspective more deeply.

Practical Tip:

The next time you provide feedback, start with a question rather than a statement. This minor adjustment can shift the tone of the entire conversation, making it more impactful, authentic, and constructive.

Feedback as Relationship Currency

Feedback doesn't just influence performance—it strengthens relationships. When delivered with intention, feedback becomes proof that you're invested in someone's development. It says, "I see you, and I care about your growth."

In The People Dividend, I emphasize that leadership is about unlocking the potential in others. Feedback is one of the most effective tools leaders have to do this. Teams thrive when they know their leaders are paying attention—not in a micromanaging sense, but in a way that offers genuine, actionable guidance.

However, feedback is only effective when trust exists. Without it, even the most thoughtfully worded input can feel like a critique. Building trust takes consistency. It's about ensuring that people know your feedback comes from a place of support, not judgment.

Practical Tip:

Ask yourself, "Have I earned the trust to give meaningful feedback?" If not, prioritize building rapport first. This might mean more one-on-one conversations or celebrating small successes before pointing out areas for improvement.

Reflective Question (from 52 Meditations):

"Do my colleagues feel safe to give me feedback?" Creating a feedback culture starts with modeling openness—listening genuinely when feedback comes your way.

Turning Feedback Into a Habit, Not a Calendar Event

Too often, feedback is confined to performance reviews or occasional check-ins. This scheduled approach makes it feel rigid and contrived—a task to cross off rather than an ongoing conversation.

Authentic leaders weave feedback into the fabric of daily interactions. It's a habit, not a calendar event. Whether it's a quick acknowledgment after a team presentation—"That was excellent clarity on slide three"—or a thoughtful question after a project delivery—"What did you learn through this process?"—micro-feedback helps normalize the practice.

One key meditation from 52 Meditations reminds us that feedback can be a "nutrient" for growth—it's the daily inputs, not just the end-of-quarter reviews, that yield the best insights. Leaders who cultivate this habit not only foster trust but keep their teams continuously improving.

Practical Tip:

Commit to delivering five pieces of micro-feedback every week. These don't need to be formal or lengthy; a simple "great work handling that tricky client call" can make a significant impact.

Inviting Feedback as a Leader

Here's one of leadership's paradoxes—the more senior you become, the less likely you are to hear the honest, unvarnished truth. Why? Because people fear repercussions or think they don't need feedback. To sustain your growth as a leader, it's crucial to reverse this dynamic.

The meditation "Inviting Deliciousness and Feedback" from 52 Meditations asks leaders to reflect on this truth critically. It challenges us to welcome feedback not as an ego threat, but as an opportunity to evolve. Authentic leadership involves modeling vulnerability.

Start small. When asking for feedback, focus on specific areas where you want to improve. For example:

• "What's one thing I could have done differently in that meeting?"
• "How can I support you better?"

These questions are disarming—they signal openness and create psychological safety, encouraging colleagues to share what they might otherwise hold back.

Practical Tip:

After receiving feedback, resist the urge to explain or defend. Say, "Thank you for sharing that. I'll reflect on it." Demonstrating humility will encourage more open feedback in the future.

Coaching Through Feedback

Leaders wear many hats, but one of their most essential roles is that of a coach. Effective feedback isn't just about pointing out what's wrong—it's about guiding people toward their best selves.

Consider this scenario. An employee has missed a critical project deadline. A transactional leader might say, "You need to meet deadlines in the future." An authentic, coaching-oriented leader might approach it differently:

• Acknowledge the issue. "The missed deadline created challenges for the team. What prevented you from completing the project on time?"
• Explore solutions. "What support would help you prevent this in the future?"
• End with encouragement. "I know you've worked hard on other deadlines; I'm confident you'll take steps to improve."

This approach doesn't just fix the immediate issue—it empowers the employee to problem-solve and grow. Coaching feedback, rooted in curiosity and care, elevates individual and team performance over time.

Practical Tip:

Include at least one open-ended, coaching question in your feedback to encourage reflection. Questions like, "What did you take away from this experience?" can turn setbacks into learning moments.

Crafting a Feedback-Rich Culture

Leadership and culture are inseparable. If you want an organization where feedback thrives, it starts with you modeling the behavior and encouraging it across all levels.

Here's how:

1. Normalize Asking for Feedback: If employees see you actively soliciting feedback, they'll feel safer doing the same.
2. Celebrate Improvement: Publicly acknowledge when someone acts on feedback and sees growth. Recognition reinforces the value of feedback.
3. Train for Feedback: Just as leaders can learn better feedback methods, employees can too. Incorporate feedback training into professional development efforts.
4. Make feedback Continuous: Shift the culture from one-time evaluations to ongoing conversations.

Creating a feedback-rich environment ensures that your organization remains adaptive, innovative, and, most importantly, connected.

Final Thoughts

Feedback isn't a luxury—it's a leadership necessity. Used wisely, it transcends its reputation as a workplace chore and becomes a superpower that drives personal and organizational growth. When we approach feedback as a tool for discovery and connection, we unlock potential—not just in others, but in ourselves as leaders.

A question worth reflecting on this week is one I pose in 52 Meditations: "How often are you receiving feedback, and what are you doing with it?" Whether you're giving it, receiving it, or creating cultures where it thrives, feedback is your opportunity to lead authentically and inspire growth at every level.

Leadership starts with intention. What intention will you set today?

‍